Why Your Readers Aren’t Turning Into Subscribers (And How to Fix It)
Most writers post and pray. They believe people will just subscribe them because their content is “good.” They won't.
You’ve got eyeballs on your content.
Great.
But why aren’t those reads turning into subscribers of your newsletter?
Let’s kill the biggest myth first: There’s no “fast” way to make this happen.
People Need 10–20 Touchpoints Before They Subscribe
Most writers post and pray. They believe people will just subscribe them because their content is “good.”
They won’t.
Humans are stubborn. Skeptical. Distracted.
Think about the last time you subscribed to something. It probably wasn’t on the first post you read. You needed to see more and you need to see it multiple times before trusting that it was worth it.
That’s how most people behave online. They need 10 to 20 interactions before hitting that button.
So, how do you shorten that cycle?
You don’t.
Just make these interactions happen and make the most out of them.
Have a conversion path.
The Conversion Path: From Free Viewers to Subscribers
Instead of waiting for people to “just” follow you, engineer the journey.
Here’s how:
1. Give Them a Taste of Your Best Content
I’m not talking about giving away your pieces of gold for free.
Just talk about them for free.
Here’s how:
You can’t expect people to subscribe before they even know what they’re subscribing for.
Instead, feed them the good stuff.
Share snippets, case studies, or condensed takeaways from your premium content. Give them just enough to want more.
Educate them about your best content.
Pro tip: have your subscribers in Kit and create a welcome value sequence designed to build relationships and showcase your value.
2. Show Them What They’re Missing
Most writers focus on what they’re giving.
Make readers feel the loss.
People hate missing out more than they love gaining something. If you want them to follow and subscribe, they need to feel the pain of not subscribing.
Try these tactics:
Highlight what subscribers are getting that readers aren’t.
Share testimonials from people who subscribed and saw results.
Use FOMO-based CTAs (Example: “Over 1,000 subscribers have already learned this — don’t miss out.”)
Pro tip: make that benefit tangible. That’s why lead magnets are so powerful. They’re a tangible asset you give in exchange for an email address.
3. Make Subscribing a No-Brainer
At the end of every free post, ask yourself: “Did I make it stupidly easy for them to subscribe?”
Here’s how to remove friction:
Have a clear CTA (Don’t just say “Subscribe.” Say why and especially what’s the result they’ll get after subscribing. e.g., “Subscribe to get weekly growth tactics that will help earn your first $1000 online”)
Use a low-risk offer (A free resource, bonus content, or even a trial period.)
Simplify the process (Use just one CTA. Not 10. Add no unnecessary steps just one click to subscribe.)
Pro tip: Don’t talk about what you give. Talk about what they get as a result after doing what you teach them. People don’t want another portion of expert advice. They want solutions to their problems. Talk about that.
Bottom Line: Don’t Wait. Ask.
Your audience isn’t going to “just” find their way to your newsletter. You have to lead them there.
Give them value. Show them what they’re missing. Make the next step stupid not to take it.
That’s how you turn passive viewers into engaged subscribers.
Now, take a look at your content —
🧐 Are you making these three steps crystal clear?
If not, start today — because those readers aren’t going to convert themselves.
Yana
👉 Get my powerful Notes Writer GPT trained to write punchy Notes that go viral and easily get you new subscribers!
Recommend Unplugged by Yana G.Y.!
Your one-stop shop to grow your Substack in 2025: get access to all the proven strategies, tactics, tools, and challenges.
👉 And if you haven’t already, join the Unplugged community and Kickstart your Substack growth:
True! Putting yourself out there with fear can paralyze your success! You have to believe in your self!